European summers play host to age-old rivalries. Yet one decision stands out: will you choose the Cyclades or the Balearics? Specifically, which is better to visit, Ibiza vs Mykonos?
Mykonos is an extroverted choice in the Aegean Sea. This Grecian paradise is fronted by endless beaches with upscale clubs, a youthful touch contrasted by historic architecture like its windmills and the hanging balconies of Little Venice. To an untrained eye, Ibiza’s architecture isn’t entirely dissimilar; both islands feature whitewashed houses. Yet, located literally oceans apart, there are some key differences.
Ibiza and Mykonos are neck-and-neck on the international stage. Deciding between the two matters, and each offers a subtly individualistic experience — from nightlife to beaches and atmosphere. Here’s how they compare and which visitors should choose
Key Differences Between Ibiza and Mykonos
Entering this comparison completely from scratch? Discerning travelers should understand the fundamental differences between these two destinations.
Ibiza
First, visualize Ibiza’s location. Situated in the Mediterranean Sea, some 1,135 nautical miles away, the Spanish island has cut its teeth on generations of dance club culture. Ibiza is the third largest of the Balearics, an island off the east coast of Spain and above Algeria. It’s roughly parallel to Benidorm, and its semi-exposed Mediterranean location guarantees gentle year-round breezes — a welcome respite in the peak summer heat. Speaking of temperatures, the island has a year-round mean average of 18.3°C, with highs of 30°C in August.
No wonder it’s such a popular summer getaway, right? The Spanish island has a permanent population of around 150,000 residents, although this rockets with temporary tourists in peak seasons.
Geologically, Ibiza comprises limestone and natural salts. In fact, prior to its tourism boom, the island carved its economy through salt extraction. Interestingly, the profits from salt exports are what actually funded the coastal wall in Dalt Vila. Today, Las Salinas — a national park encompassed by 75% salt water — is protected by UNESCO. Ibiza’s terrain also includes coastal beaches and inland pine forests.
- Ibiza is a Spanish island
- Ibiza is located in the Mediterranean Sea
- Ibiza has average temperatures of 18.3°C, with highs of 30°C in August
- The terrain is a mixture of salt flats, beaches, and pine forests
- The island’s economy initially relied on salt extraction
- Ibiza has a reputation for clubbing holidays
Mykonos
Mykonos is miles away. This island is amongst the smallest Cyclades and is located in the Aegean Sea — just off the mainland’s coastline. It sits southeast of Athens in a similarly exposed location that leaves it blustery year-round. Hence, it invested in its (now iconic) windmills. Prior to tourism, Mykonos relied heavily on maritime and agriculture, and these windmills were key for creating bread for sailors.
The average year-round temperature in Mykonos is almost identical (18.1°C). Yet summers are slightly cooler, maxing out at 28.5°C in July. The population is also substantially smaller, with under 10,000 permanent residents as opposed to Ibiza’s 150,000.
Unlike Ibiza, Mykonos is geologically formed from granite. Mykonos is exceptionally barren, with only drought-resistant plants and no rivers. Residents rely on two artificial lakes for water, but the low-lying topography does create easily accessible beaches and enables consistent breezes.
- Mykonos is a Greek island
- Mykonos is located in the Aegean Sea
- Mykonos has average temperatures of 18.1°C, with highs of 28.5°C in July
- The flat terrain is barren and relies on artificial lakes for water supply
- The island’s economy initially relied on agriculture and maritime industries
- Mykonos has a reputation for beach clubs and boutique getaways
Ibiza vs Mykonos: Vibes & Atmosphere
With a thorough introduction under your belt, it’s time to embrace the fun sides of these islands. There are distinct differences between the vibes on Ibiza vs Mykonos.
Ibiza
Summary: Frivolous fun
“Vibes” are at Ibiza’s very soul. According to legend, the island is the third most magnetic spot in the world. The frivolous and energized atmosphere is amped on by Es Vedra, a natural rock formation visited at sunset to sap its “power.”
Unfortunately for Ibiza, its fun and carefree atmosphere has suffered a slight PR disaster in recent years. The island originally began to accrue music-loving crowds as a movement of free-spirited hippies in the 1960s and 70s. Yet it became associated with low-cost 18-30 package holidays in later years and only began fighting this stereotype over the last decade. The truth is that Ibiza’s atmosphere depends on where you stay.
Playa Den Bossa and San Antonio are where to head should you wish to embrace the hedonism of the island’s infamous nightlife. While, in the north, Portinatx is a beautiful place to embrace bohemian serenity in a former fishing village. In summary? The island is fun and friendly, with an undercurrent of lingering hippie heritage.
Mykonos
Summary: High-brow hedonism
Rather than being “hippified,” Mykonos pioneers a distinctly more cosmopolitan atmosphere. While the island hosts a hot rotation of world-renowned DJs, it leans more heavily towards the pursuit of a boutique aesthetic. Everything conveys Aegean beauty — from its Cycladic windmills to the whitewashed buildings of Little Venice.
Mykonos had an interesting journey to tourism. Initially, urbanites and scholars flocked to the island, fascinated by the ruins on its neighboring island of Delos. That cultured aspect of Mykonos set the tone for the decades to come; throughout the 50s and 60s, it maintained a high-brow allure. Despite emerging hedonism, Mykonos continued to tailor experiences to a luxury-seeking crowd — including designer stores and boutique beach clubs.
Winner: Draw
It’s impossible to select a winner based on atmosphere alone. Ultimately, it’s subjective. Do you want high-brow hedonism on Mykonos? Or frivolous fun in Ibiza?
Nightlife Showdown: Ibiza vs Mykonos
That difference in vibes? It really sets the stage for the contrast between Ibizan and Myconian nightlife. Here’s how the party islands weigh up.
Ibiza
Summary: Nearly non-stop partying
Ibiza lives and breathes party culture. Travelers can bar hop San Antonio’s West End Strip, dance to international names at mega-clubs like Ushuaïa, or vibe at bohemian beach clubs.
Is there any better way to embrace nightlife? Ibiza also runs a lengthy party-centric calendar, with official raves and club events from April until October.
Mykonos
Summary: Luxurious parties in specific seasons
Mykonos is like a grown-up version of Ibiza; think slightly formal, with a focus on luxury. It’s worth checking out the best clubs in Mykonos beforehand. Take Cavo Paradiso, for instance; this club combines energy-infused partying with a sushi bar.
In contrast, it’s equally important to research when the Mykonos party season is. The island runs a shorter schedule, with most events limited to that July to August window.
Winner: Ibiza
In the nightlife category, Ibiza is a clear winner. The partying is varied, and the party season runs considerably longer.
There is an argument to be made for the allure of “keeping it classy” on Mykonos, but ultimately, Ibiza practically created the European party island movement. You’re looking at the original.
Ibiza vs Mykonos: Where are the Best Beaches?
Everyone loves the rejuvenation of hot days spent on beautiful beaches. So, which does it better? Are the beaches better in Ibiza or Mykonos?
Ibiza
Summary: Beautiful beaches with plenty of quiet coves
Ibiza has a coastline of 200 km and 80 beaches. It’s not just the sheer number of options, though. The island has six beaches with Blue Flag status, and with its limestone geology, many fascinating landscapes with hidden-away coves and offshore rock formations like Es Vedra. Consider the following:
- Las Salinas: A youthful beach backed by bars and constant music
- Cala Mastella: A tiny cove and seafood restaurant (rumored to have turned away the reservation-less King of Spain)
- Cala Jondal: An upmarket beach with a permanent shuttle service to transport those arriving by yacht to the shores
Mykonos
Summary: Stunning beaches with large expanses of sand
Mykonos has nearly half of Ibiza’s coastline (almost 90 km versus 200 km). However, that doesn’t cramp its coastal style; the island is renowned for its accessible and spacious sandy beaches.
- Kalafatis: The island’s only Blue Flag beach
- Platys Gialos: Family-friendly with shallow waters for swimming
- Psarou: A trendy beach with moored yachts and sunbeds
One caveat: Mykonos has just one Blue Flag beach. Interestingly, Spain beat Greece to the title of the world’s cleanest beaches, too.
Winner: Ibiza
It’s easy to see why Ibiza vs Mykonos is such a hot debate. Yet Ibiza steals a little extra spotlight by having cleaner coastlines.
Cost Comparison: Is Ibiza or Mykonos More Expensive?
There is so much entertainment to be had. By savvily factoring in a cost comparison, it’s possible to choose a destination that allows you to maximize your budget on “fun” and limit unnecessary budget leaks.
So, which is more expensive? Mykonos or Ibiza? Let’s take to Numbeo for some solid statistics.
Ibiza
Summary: Drink deals
Ibiza has plenty of package deals. The island has made a business out of low-cost party packages — expect beer prices around a happy €3 mark.
Still, don’t underestimate mounting costs. Food is expensive in Ibiza. Expect average bills of €15 at inexpensive restaurants and €80 for a mid-range, three-course meal for two.
Mykonos
Summary: Expensive venues
Mykonos caters to a luxurious crowd, so the reality is that tourists will see a pricier side than residents. Expensive beach clubs and accommodation are the real budget killers. Still, the splurge is worthwhile; just look at the gorgeous Mykonos villas for rent.
The good news for Mykonos is that (outside of expensive club venues) dining is cheaper. The average meal cost is €12 at an inexpensive restaurant and €50 for a mid-range, three-course meal for two. However, partiers will be disappointed at drink costs, closer to €5 for domestic and international beers.
Winner: Mykonos
It might be a back-handed compliment, but Mykonos wins this round. The island has quieter areas for low-cost dining, but those seeking out luxury will find it comes at a higher price. Stick to Ibiza for package deals and cheaper rates.